Monday, March 26, 2012

RNs, PSWs, WTF? A reply to Anonymous

In reply to my last post on the schedule, Anonymous wrote:

the bottom line is that they are psw's with 10mnths training. the bottom of the healthcare foodchain looking after the most vunerable people! this was the job of Rn's in days gone by but the government wont pay that much! go figure.

(BTW, Anonymous, would you mind signing a name with your comments? It doesn't have to be your full name or a real name, I would just like something to call you by. I feel rude otherwise.)

I think Anonymous makes an important point here, and I wanted to discuss it. I am not sure I agree with her conclusions, however.

The vast majority of attendant care in Canada is provided by what are known as Personal Support Workers (PSWs). There is not a lot of training for this job, and the shitty pay reflects that. They are NOT registered nurses (RNs) and are not qualified to do the things nurses do, such as administer medication. The PSW job is popular with immigrant populations, as it is a quick and relatively easy qualification to get.

This is a problem, but not necessarily for the reasons Anonymous stated. Having an RN around is great...when you're sick. Nurses have had to pass nursing school, which generally means they are highly motivated to do their jobs, and they generally care about their patients and want them to be comfortable and get well. However, most people with disabilities are not sick and do not need nursing care (and the nursing attitude that comes with it. God, the attitude) all the time.

The problem with many PSWs (not all) is twofold:

1. The language barrier. PSWs must be able to take direction from either clients or those responsible for them. If they cannot understand the instructions, and many cannot, it puts both the client and the PSW in danger. I have heard that PSWs must pass a written English test. This is useless. In their jobs, PSWs don't need to write well. They need to be able to understand oral instructions quickly and completely.

2. Lack of vocation. To put it bluntly, cleaning up shit is not a high-status job, and many people take it because that's all they can get, and will move on as soon as they can. This often means they will not do a very good job while they are around, either. I mean, it's just people with disabilities, right? Who cares if they are comfortable or happy? This is something no amount of training can fix.

To be honest, I don't think more training is the answer. Where I used to live, attendant care was provided by fellow students, none of whom even had the qualifications of a PSW. A lot of them didn't have a vocation either; it was something people did because it was more interesting than working at campus food services. But because we were equals and required to treat each other that way, it worked out most of the time. You wouldn't leave a friend of yours sitting in her own urine, so you wouldn't leave a client in it either. Likewise, you wouldn't scream and yell at your friends (mostly) so you wouldn't at your attendants either (mostly.) The fact that we were around the same age helped; there was more empathy there.

More empathy, I think, is the answer. And I have no idea how to build that into the health care system.

1 comment:

  1. Was the service better from fellow students? It sounds progressive. Have you thought about living there again? Did you have to schedule things there?

    Adam

    ReplyDelete